A new method could take the guesswork out of mixing drug cocktails.
Drug cocktails, such as those for treating cancer, are best when the proper ingredients are mixed in the right proportions – just like the alcoholic versions offered at the local bar. And like the cocktails we normally drink, the sum of the parts can be better than the ingredients on their own – or we can be left with unwanted side effects. Published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science (PNAS), a new model developed in the group of Prof. Uri Alon of the Weizmann Institute of Science’s Department of Molecular Cell Biology can simplify the process of identifying the optimal blends for drug cocktails – even when a large number of ingredients is called for.
Drug cocktails – both antibiotic and anti-cancer – are increasingly used because, among other things, simultaneously attacking pathogenic cells with several different methods can reduce the risk of drug resistance. And doctors and pharmaceutical companies are interested in the advance of drug “mixology” because it can help create novel applications for existing drugs, since new ones are costly to develop and slow to reach the market.
But adding drugs together does not generally result just in the sum of their effects. For instance, one drug can alert mechanisms in a cell that pump the other drugs out of the cell, thus changing the dose at which the other drugs will be effective. Conversely, side effects can add up, so researchers often want to identify the lowest possible dose of any given drug. And with typically four or more drugs added together in chemotherapy cocktails, the number of possible combinations and doses is astronomical: it would be impossible to test them all to arrive at the optimal mix. This hurdle is known as the “combinatorial explosion problem.”
Adding drugs together does not generally result just in the sum of their effects
Because of the combinatorial explosion problem, say research students Anat Zimmer and Itay Katzir, who led the study, drug cocktails are often concocted without any good way of predicting the end result. Zimmer, Katzir, and Prof. Alon developed a method that requires only a small number of measurements on drug pairs, thus bypassing the need for an astronomical number of measurements.
The tests are conducted on human cancer cells or bacteria grown in lab dishes. The group tested each drug – separately and in pairs – to understand the effects at several different doses. This enabled the researchers to determine how drug A affects the actions of drug B, and vice versa; the new mathematical model was then extrapolated to predict the interactions among three, four, and more drugs in combination. Further testing showed that the model performs better than existing methods of dealing with the combinatorial explosion problem; thus, researchers using the model would not need to test every possible combination to arrive at the optimal doses in drug cocktails.
“There is an urgent demand for methods that can predict how drug cocktails will work,” says Katzir. “This model may take much of the expensive guesswork out of the process of developing such cocktails.”
“The model might prove especially useful for personalized medicine – for example, in cancer – because each tumor can react differently to the same drugs,” adds Zimmer. “It provides a way to mix that perfect cocktail without having to try out all of the possible combinations.”
Prof. Uri Alon’s research is supported by the Benoziyo Endowment Fund for the Advancement of Science; the David and Fela Shapell Family Foundation INCPM Fund for Preclinical Studies; the Jeanne and Joseph Nissim Foundation for Life Sciences Research; the Gurwin Family Fund for Scientific Research; the Kahn Foundation; the Mauerberger Foundation Fund; Katy and Gary Leff, Calabasas, CA; and Dr. Miriam Netzer, Forest Hills, NY. Prof. Alon is the incumbent of the Abisch-Frenkel Professorial Chair.